Twelve sections covering the single editable file, the two signed files that
must never be touched, safe ways to open a UTF-8 CSV, every one of the 14
columns, the exact attestation string, a worked example, the five decision
groups, the validation command, and what done looks like.
Two prohibitions are stated explicitly: do not edit the signed reviewer files,
and do not run build_human_review_packets.py, which overwrites them with blank
templates. Also flags that adjudicators cannot use needs_source even though
52 rows carry it from reviewer 1.
Every hardcoded string was verified against source: the attestation matches the
validator byte for byte, the allowed final_decision set matches, all 14 columns
are covered with no phantom or missing ones, and all six referenced paths exist.
Corrects an earlier claim in the record. The review_date problem is not one
problem. Reviewer 2 has 2026/9/20 on all 84 rows, a pure formatting issue.
Reviewer 1 has 84 distinct dates incrementing daily to 2026/12/12 - an Excel
drag-fill, mostly future-dated. That column cannot be fixed by reformatting,
since the values themselves are wrong; only reviewer 1 can supply the real date.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fills reviewer_1_decision, reviewer_2_decision and conflict_reason for all 84
rows (252 cells) so adjudicators can work from one sheet. Every adjudicator
field stays blank: identity, date, final_*, notes and attestation are human
attestation and the script neither writes them nor overwrites existing values.
conflict_reason follows the validator's actual rule (decisions differ, or
reviewer_1 is not a plain approve) and states only the mechanical reason plus
both decisions - no interpretation. 63 rows differ, 21 agree but are not plain
approve, so all 84 require adjudication.
Adds a purpose-built script rather than fixing at the usual build source:
build_human_review_packets.py overwrites both signed reviewer CSVs with blank
templates at lines 39-40, so running it would destroy 84 rows of signed human
review. It was not run. The new script re-hashes both signed packets before and
after and exits FATAL if either changed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Read-only diagnostic. The 63 rows reduce to three systematic blocks, each a
single policy question rather than per-row judgment: YRBS numeric value-label
sourcing (27), GSHS population/mapping evidence (18), and language status
(18). Also records that YRBS 2023 Q27-Q29 can be closed from the local CDC
format program rather than adjudicated, and that the adjudication table's
three machine-derivable columns are still blank.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Implements only what reviewer 1 and reviewer 2 independently and concordantly
required, at the build sources rather than in generated files:
- NSDUH 2022/2023/2024 YUSUITHK: strip the codebook editorial note about the
2022 section move from question_text. It was never shown to respondents.
The removed text is kept verbatim in notes.
- NSDUH 2021 YUSUITHK: drop the stray space before the final question mark.
- Solomon Islands items: review_status provisional -> needs_source. No country
questionnaire, codebook or fact sheet ships under Dataset/; the only citation
is the generic GSHS data dictionary. Keyed off the missing instrument, not
hardcoded per country.
Also downgrades two design claims that A-20260920-067 verified as unsupported:
Jamaica and Wallis and Futuna report a census with a 100% school response rate
but carried the same Taylor-linearization plan as the two-stage cluster
samples. design_status becomes census_variance_treatment_unresolved and two
conflict records are added. variance_method itself is untouched - that is a
Stage 4 statistical decision needing its own evidence.
Deliberately not done: the instruction sentence missing from the 2021 stem is
left absent rather than written in, since that would be composing official
question text; and the 84 adjudications remain human work. Only 21 of 84 rows
are concordant, so 63 need adjudication.
84 item_version_id unchanged, response_dictionary byte-identical, both signed
reviewer CSVs unchanged. Gate 1 audit passes all seven machine deliverables and
stays blocked solely on two_actual_human_reviewers.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Runs the four Stage 1 build scripts under .venv-research (python 3.12.14,
pandas 3.0.6, numpy 2.5.3, pyarrow 25.0.1, duckdb 1.5.5 - all matching
python-requirements.lock.txt), clearing the environment mismatch that halted
A-20260920-068. Brings generated artifacts back in line with the sources
corrected in 0c9645e.
Diff verified item by item: all 84 item_version_id unchanged, response
dictionary keys identical, and the only changes are the four authorized
corrections - YRBS 1995/1997 Louisiana exclusion, NSDUH attempt source
attribution and verification status, the five unattested inherited codes
marked needs_source, and the Morocco / Wallis and Futuna questionnaire
references switched to the stored text language.
Both signed reviewer CSVs are byte-identical before and after. Gate 1
acceptance audit still passes all seven machine deliverables and remains
blocked solely on two_actual_human_reviewers; Gate 1 stays in_progress.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The first push attempt failed with an expired credential; retrying the same
command after committing the record succeeded. All seven pending commits are
now on origin/main and local is 0 ahead. Clears the push_pending status
carried by A-20260920-066/067/068.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Stage 1 remains in_progress. Remote git.jinome.org is reachable from the
Windows locked environment; the blocker is an expired GCM refresh token with
no access-token entry, and this session runs with GCM_INTERACTIVE=never, so
re-authorization must be done by the user. No credentials were read, modified
or cleared. Stale .git/index.lock and .git/refs/heads/.writetest from an
earlier crashed git process were removed and the index resynced with HEAD.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A-20260920-068. Backup taken, no build script run, generated artefacts
untouched. This shell has Python 3.10.12 / pandas 2.3.3 and no pyarrow,
while the project pins Python 3.12.14 / pandas 3.0.6 / pyarrow 25.0.1;
pyarrow cannot be installed here (proxy 403) and .venv-research is a
Windows venv. Rebuilding under pandas 2.x would make the item bank and
response dictionary irreproducible against the recorded environment.
Records the exact commands to run in the pinned Windows environment and
the diff expected from the corrections in 0c9645e.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016yuKikAXbByLvsUnh55SRd
A-20260920-067. All ten checkable claims in the reviewer 2 findings were
re-verified directly against local sources rather than against the
project audit trail, and all ten hold. Records the evidence per claim,
the three source-level corrections in 0c9645e, the verified findings
left uncorrected as out of scope this round, and push_pending.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016yuKikAXbByLvsUnh55SRd
Applies the three source-attested corrections from the signed reviews.
All are made in the generators, not the generated CSVs, which would be
overwritten on the next build.
YRBS population: the 1995 and 1997 National User Guides state the frame
covers "the fifty states and the District of Columbia, excluding a
majority of Louisiana". 1993 and 1999 carry no such restriction, so the
string is now year-conditional in both the item audit and the design
record instead of claiming plain national coverage for every year.
NSDUH attempt: source_file was None because the codebook render was
pending. The local MRB specification PDFs carry YSUI03 verbatim for all
four years, including the [IF CURNTAGE = 12 - 17] condition, so each
year now cites its local instrument and the status moves to
local_instrument_pdf_verified.
NSDUH attempt codes: YUSUICTRY appears in no local dictionary or schema,
yet carried nine codes identical to the ideation variable YUSUITHK. The
instrument offers only 1-4 plus DK/REF, so 85/94/97/98/99 are now marked
unattested and inherited, and those dictionary rows become needs_source.
GSHS citation: the questionnaire selector took the first document whose
role contained "questionnaire", which cited a French instrument for
English question_text in the Morocco and Wallis and Futuna components.
It now prefers the version matching the stored wording. Verified against
all six components; the other four are unchanged.
Generated artefacts are deliberately NOT rebuilt here: that regenerates
the item bank and the human review queue and is gate-relevant.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016yuKikAXbByLvsUnh55SRd
Correct A-20260920-065, which stated the four human identity and
signature fields were empty; both reviewer packets were signed after
that entry was written.
Add A-20260920-066 covering this Git action: the 37-file CRLF flip
carried no content change and was neutralised with .gitattributes
rather than committed as 23k lines of noise; validator output is
recorded as failed on review_date format and outstanding adjudication.
Push status is push_pending, not pushed: git.jinome.org is unreachable
from both execution environments in this session (proxy returns HTTP
403 on CONNECT). No credentials were read or changed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016yuKikAXbByLvsUnh55SRd
Both reviewer packets are signed on all 84 rows: reviewer 1 Jino Gu,
reviewer 2 Jinghao Guo, each row carrying the independence attestation.
Reviewer 1: 52 needs_source, 32 approve_with_correction.
Reviewer 2: 45 approve, 32 approve_with_correction, 7 needs_source.
validate_human_reviews.py returns status=failed on two counts, both
recorded rather than worked around: review_date is written 2026/9/20
where ISO YYYY-MM-DD is required (168 rows), and all 84 items still
await adjudication. Signed rows were not edited. Gate 1 stays
in_progress; no item bank or response layer was rebuilt.
Adds ERR-20260920-043 and the reviewer summaries, including reviewer
2's findings on NSDUH source attestation, the GSHS French
mis-citation, census vs cluster design treatment, and the YRBS
1995/1997 Louisiana population caveat.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016yuKikAXbByLvsUnh55SRd
Add .gitattributes with '* text=auto eol=lf' so Windows CRLF working
copies no longer surface as whole-file content changes; 37 tracked files
had flipped LF->CRLF with zero content change.
Ignore /tmp/ session scratch and research/experiments/node_modules, a
Windows junction git records as a symlink so **/node_modules/ misses it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016yuKikAXbByLvsUnh55SRd
