diff --git a/Progression.md b/Progression.md index 733a9b8..de6d87a 100644 --- a/Progression.md +++ b/Progression.md @@ -1,9 +1,9 @@ # 项目进度档案 -版本：1.11 +版本：1.12 建立日期：2026-09-20 当前总状态：`in_progress` -当前阶段：阶段 1 `in_progress`；NSDUH、GSHS 与 YRBS 主要结局来源均已直接核验，YRBS 21 条错误映射已纠正；缺失规则、Solomon Islands 来源和双人审核尚未完成 +当前阶段：阶段 1 `in_progress`；三套调查主要结局来源均已直接核验，YRBS 21 条错误映射已纠正，GSHS 7 个组件均有直接条目来源；缺失规则和双人审核尚未完成 ## 1. 管理规则 @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ | 阶段 | 名称 | 状态 | 当前判定 | |---|---|---|---| | 0 | 冻结研究问题、范围与版本 | `passed` | 四项交付物齐备，Gate 0 已通过；研究工具链补强与锁定完成 | -| 1 | 有来源证据的题库和回答层 | `in_progress` | 数据契约、入口审计及三套调查主要结局直接来源核验已完成；YRBS 错误列映射已纠正；缺失规则、Solomon Islands 来源、2021/2023 导入和人工双重审核尚未完成 | +| 1 | 有来源证据的题库和回答层 | `in_progress` | 数据契约、入口审计及三套调查主要结局直接来源核验已完成；YRBS 错误列映射已纠正；缺失规则、2021/2023 导入和人工双重审核尚未完成 | | 2 | 可行性、可识别性和连接审计 | `not_started` | 等待 Gate 1 | | 3 | 冻结验证协议与已知真值模拟 | `not_started` | 等待 Gate 2 | | 4 | 直接协调和传统基线 | `not_started` | 等待 Gate 3 | @@ -87,7 +87,7 @@ Gate 0 当前判定：`passed`。四项交付物齐备；目标总体政策、 | P1 | R、PyMC/ArviZ、心理测量包与 CUDA Toolkit 曾缺失 | 已解决：项目 Python/R 环境和 CUDA 端到端验收通过 | 后续仅按锁定文件维护；任何升级必须重跑三套烟雾测试 | | P1 | 文献初筛尚未形成可审计矩阵 | 研究定位和“贡献”表述仍不稳定 | 建立 literature matrix，记录 DOI、来源、证据层级和项目关系 | | P0 | NSDUH 的 `YSUI03/YUSUICTRY` 已确认施测，但尝试及严重度字段不在当前本地公开使用数据中；2024 指南明确记录派生尝试变量因披露风险排除 | 当前微数据只能外部验证意念/计划，不能验证尝试 | 不从其他题推导尝试；如核心设计必须使用尝试，评估受限数据申请或预先设计的聚合结果方案 | -| P1 | GSHS 已证明 `_b_` 为派生/重复表示，但 Solomon Islands 2023 缺本地直接来源；YRBS 2021/2023 仍处于导入隔离 | 不能批准全部题目家族或把后两年纳入回答层 | 获取 Solomon Islands 来源；按官方 SAS 布局验证 YRBS 2021/2023 导入 | +| P1 | Solomon Islands 2023 已有 WHO 官方目录的逐题来源与总体资料，但未取得国家问卷文件/实际施测语言证据；YRBS 2021/2023 仍处于导入隔离 | 不影响该组件的题文/编码来源，但限制语言字段批准；后两年不能进入回答层 | 保持语言 provisional；按官方 SAS 布局验证 YRBS 2021/2023 导入 | ## 8. 行动日志 @@ -735,6 +735,18 @@ Gate 0 当前判定：`passed`。四项交付物齐备；目标总体政策、 - 推送状态：`pushed`；研究增量提交 `a7ac525` 已推送至 `origin/main`。 - 下一步：建立三套调查主要结局的正式回答字典与保守缺失规则，生成双人审核队列；并定位 Solomon Islands 2023 GSHS 直接来源。 +### A-20260920-058：补齐 Solomon Islands 2023 GSHS 官方条目来源 + +- 时间：2026-09-20 +- 阶段：1（有来源证据的题库和回答层） +- 动作：行动前完整读取工作流与进度档案并核对干净 Git 状态；检索 WHO NCD Microdata Repository 的 `SLB_2023_GSHS_v01` 研究页和三个逐题变量页；把官方目录证据纳入 GSHS 组件审计与主要结局登记。 +- 输入：WHO catalog 992 study metadata；变量 `V39`（意念）、`V40`（计划）、`V41`（尝试）；本地 Solomon Islands 1,995 行组件。 +- 输出：GSHS 组件审计升级至 v1.1，主要结局登记升级至 v1.4；所有七个有主要结局的 GSHS 组件现均有直接条目来源。 +- 检查：官方目录的三项 literal question、1/2 或 1–5 回答类别、有效/无效例数与本地组件逐项一致：意念 1,890/105、计划 1,953/42、尝试 1,963/32；研究页明确总体为 13–17 岁在校青少年、Form 1–6，并描述两阶段整群抽样。脚本重跑后直接条目来源为 7/7、待来源为 0。 +- 质量边界：未在官方 related-materials 中取得 2023 国家问卷文件，实际施测语言仍不能由英语目录元数据推断；因此语言字段保持 `provisional`。这不再是题文、编码或总体来源缺口。 +- 推送状态：`push_pending`；待本行动校验、提交并推送后回写提交号。 +- 下一步：生成三套调查正式回答字典、保守缺失规则及双人审核队列；随后验证 YRBS 2021/2023 导入。 + ## 9. 剩余工作量估算（2026-09-20 基线） | 阶段 | 主要工作 | 预计人周 | 主要波动来源 | @@ -758,5 +770,5 @@ Gate 0 当前判定：`passed`。四项交付物齐备；目标总体政策、 阶段 1 下一行动： 1. 形成三套调查主要结局的回答编码/缺失规则草案，并把需要两名实际审核者处理的记录导出为审核队列； -2. 获取或定位 Solomon Islands 2023 GSHS 的国家问卷/代码本； -3. 按官方 SAS 布局验证 YRBS 2021/2023 导入，在验证前继续隔离。 +2. 按官方 SAS 布局验证 YRBS 2021/2023 导入，在验证前继续隔离； +3. 人工审核前保持全部主要结局为 `provisional`，不把 AI 预审写成双人审核。 diff --git a/research/stage1/audit_gshs_primary_outcome_components.py b/research/stage1/audit_gshs_primary_outcome_components.py index 8a23d11..868dd08 100644 --- a/research/stage1/audit_gshs_primary_outcome_components.py +++ b/research/stage1/audit_gshs_primary_outcome_components.py @@ -136,6 +136,14 @@ SOURCE_PACKAGES = { }, } +SOLOMON_COMPONENT = "SLB_2023_GSHS_v01::slb_2023" +SOLOMON_CATALOG_SOURCES = [ + ("https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992/variable/V39", "ideation variable metadata"), + ("https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992/variable/V40", "plan variable metadata"), + ("https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992/variable/V41", "attempt variable metadata"), + ("https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992", "study universe and sampling metadata"), +] + def sha256(path: Path) -> str: digest = hashlib.sha256() @@ -187,6 +195,17 @@ def scan_data() -> dict: def source_package(component_id: str) -> dict: package = SOURCE_PACKAGES.get(component_id) if package is None: + if component_id == SOLOMON_COMPONENT: + return { + "status": "official_catalog_item_metadata_verified", + "documents": [ + {"source_url": url, "role": role, "page_or_section": "WHO NCD Microdata Repository catalog"} + for url, role in SOLOMON_CATALOG_SOURCES + ], + "question_numbers": None, + "source_language_evidence": ["English catalog literal-question metadata"], + "note": "The official catalog provides literal questions, response categories, case counts, universe, and sampling metadata. A country questionnaire file and actual administration-language evidence were not located.", + } return { "status": "pending_local_direct_source", "documents": [], @@ -254,7 +273,11 @@ def build_audit() -> dict: "collection_start": meta["collection_start"], "survey_component": meta["survey_component"], "survey_scope": meta["survey_scope"], - "population": "school-attending students; exact sampled ages/grades remain pending component source review", + "population": ( + "school-going adolescents aged 13-17 years; Form 1-Form 6; all students in selected classes eligible" + if component_id == SOLOMON_COMPONENT + else "school-attending students; exact sampled ages/grades remain pending component source review" + ), "observed_rows": observed_rows, "canonical_relative_path": meta["canonical_relative_path"], "catalog_url": meta["catalog_url"], @@ -290,11 +313,10 @@ def build_audit() -> dict: ) available = [component for component in components if component["primary_outcomes_observed"]] - direct_sources = [ - component for component in available if component["source_package"]["status"] == "local_questionnaire_and_codebooks_located" - ] + local_sources = [component for component in available if component["source_package"]["status"] == "local_questionnaire_and_codebooks_located"] + direct_sources = [component for component in available if component["source_package"]["status"] != "pending_local_direct_source"] return { - "schema_version": "1.0", + "schema_version": "1.1", "generated_on": "2026-09-20", "status": "provisional", "purpose": "Gate 1 component-level coverage and provenance audit for GSHS suicide ideation, plan, and attempt.", @@ -308,8 +330,11 @@ def build_audit() -> dict: "selected_components": len(components), "components_with_primary_outcomes": len(available), "components_without_primary_outcomes": len(components) - len(available), - "components_with_local_direct_sources": len(direct_sources), - "components_pending_local_direct_source": len(available) - len(direct_sources), + "components_with_direct_item_sources": len(direct_sources), + "components_with_local_direct_sources": len(local_sources), + "components_with_local_questionnaire_packages": len(local_sources), + "components_with_official_catalog_only": len(direct_sources) - len(local_sources), + "components_pending_direct_item_source": len(available) - len(direct_sources), "observed_rows": sum(scan["row_counts"].values()), "row_count_mismatches": len(row_count_mismatches), }, @@ -372,13 +397,13 @@ def render_markdown(audit: dict) -> str: "", "## Source boundary", "", - f"Local questionnaires plus raw and binary codebooks were located for {audit['summary']['components_with_local_direct_sources']} of the 7 components: Ghana, India, Jamaica, Mongolia, Morocco, and Wallis and Futuna. No country-specific Solomon Islands 2023 questionnaire/codebook was found locally, so that component remains pending direct-source acquisition.", + f"Local questionnaires plus raw and binary codebooks were located for {audit['summary']['components_with_local_questionnaire_packages']} components: Ghana, India, Jamaica, Mongolia, Morocco, and Wallis and Futuna. For Solomon Islands, the official WHO catalog directly provides the three literal questions, response categories, case counts, universe, and sampling metadata. A country questionnaire file and administration-language evidence were not located, so those narrower provenance fields remain pending.", "", "Available English/French/Mongolian files establish wording evidence but do not by themselves prove the language administered to every respondent. Exact sampled ages/grades, component-specific eligibility, and canonical missing reasons also remain unresolved.", "", "## Gate 1 decision", "", - "Gate 1 remains **in progress**. This audit resolves the 191-component coverage question and the raw-versus-`_b_` representation issue, but it does not satisfy the population/missing-rule or two-human-reviewer requirements. All records remain provisional and are not approved for confirmatory analysis or anchor construction.", + "Gate 1 remains **in progress**. This audit resolves the 191-component coverage question, direct item-source coverage, and the raw-versus-`_b_` representation issue, but it does not satisfy all population/language/missing-rule or two-human-reviewer requirements. All records remain provisional and are not approved for confirmatory analysis or anchor construction.", "", "## Reproduction", "", diff --git a/research/stage1/build_primary_outcome_registry.py b/research/stage1/build_primary_outcome_registry.py index 1dc8799..6fbf034 100644 --- a/research/stage1/build_primary_outcome_registry.py +++ b/research/stage1/build_primary_outcome_registry.py @@ -92,7 +92,7 @@ def build_gshs() -> tuple[list[dict], list[dict]]: "source_url": None, "page_or_section": "Master_Columns plus component-specific questionnaire/codebook references in component audit", "present_in_local_data": True, - "source_verification_status": "direct_local_sources_verified_for_six_of_seven_observed_components", + "source_verification_status": "direct_sources_verified_for_all_seven_observed_components_six_local_packages_one_official_catalog", "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": None, "reviewer_2": None, @@ -104,7 +104,7 @@ def build_gshs() -> tuple[list[dict], list[dict]]: "construct": GSHS_CONSTRUCT[variable], "record_type": "administered_raw_candidate", "question_text": GSHS_QUESTION[variable], - "notes": "Country questionnaires and ordinary codebooks identify this as an administered item. Solomon Islands 2023 direct local source remains pending; population and missing rules are not approved.", + "notes": "Country questionnaires/ordinary codebooks cover six components; official WHO catalog item metadata covers Solomon Islands 2023. Administration language and missing rules are not approved.", } ) records.append(common) @@ -270,7 +270,7 @@ def render_markdown(registry: dict) -> str: lines = [ "# Primary outcome source registry", "", - "Version: 1.3 | Status: provisional | Generated: 2026-09-20", + "Version: 1.4 | Status: provisional | Generated: 2026-09-20", "", "## Scope and decision boundary", "", @@ -283,7 +283,7 @@ def render_markdown(registry: dict) -> str: ] for survey in ["GSHS", "YRBS", "NSDUH"]: boundary = { - "GSHS": "Three administered items occur in 7/191 components; local direct sources cover 6/7, with Solomon Islands pending.", + "GSHS": "Three administered items occur in 7/191 components; six local source packages plus WHO catalog metadata cover all seven.", "YRBS": "51 annual candidates directly cross-checked; 21 prior mappings corrected; 2021/2023 data remain quarantined.", "NSDUH": "Attempt is administered as YSUI03/YUSUICTRY, but the raw and recoded attempt fields are absent from the local public-use package.", }[survey] @@ -306,7 +306,7 @@ def render_markdown(registry: dict) -> str: "", "## Gate 1 status", "", - "Gate 1 remains **in progress**. Before any candidate can enter confirmatory analysis, the project still needs the Solomon Islands GSHS source, exact population and skip-logic verification, canonical response/missing rules, validated YRBS 2021/2023 imports, and two actual human reviewers for primary outcomes.", + "Gate 1 remains **in progress**. Before any candidate can enter confirmatory analysis, the project still needs exact remaining population/language and skip-logic verification, canonical response/missing rules, validated YRBS 2021/2023 imports, and two actual human reviewers for primary outcomes.", "", "## Reproduction", "", @@ -321,7 +321,7 @@ def main() -> None: yrbs = build_yrbs() nsduh_raw, nsduh_derived, nsduh_excluded = build_nsduh() registry = { - "schema_version": "1.3", + "schema_version": "1.4", "generated_on": "2026-09-20", "status": "provisional", "allowed_uses": ["pipeline_development", "source_review_queue"], diff --git a/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.json b/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.json index 04ebcd4..4ec1626 100644 --- a/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.json +++ b/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "schema_version": "1.0", + "schema_version": "1.1", "generated_on": "2026-09-20", "status": "provisional", "purpose": "Gate 1 component-level coverage and provenance audit for GSHS suicide ideation, plan, and attempt.", @@ -13,8 +13,11 @@ "selected_components": 191, "components_with_primary_outcomes": 7, "components_without_primary_outcomes": 184, + "components_with_direct_item_sources": 7, "components_with_local_direct_sources": 6, - "components_pending_local_direct_source": 1, + "components_with_local_questionnaire_packages": 6, + "components_with_official_catalog_only": 1, + "components_pending_direct_item_source": 0, "observed_rows": 673499, "row_count_mismatches": 0 }, @@ -6870,7 +6873,7 @@ "collection_start": "2023-08", "survey_component": "", "survey_scope": "component", - "population": "school-attending students; exact sampled ages/grades remain pending component source review", + "population": "school-going adolescents aged 13-17 years; Form 1-Form 6; all students in selected classes eligible", "observed_rows": 1995, "canonical_relative_path": "raw/microdata/SLB_2023_GSHS_v01/SLB-2023.dta", "catalog_url": "https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992", @@ -6923,11 +6926,34 @@ } }, "source_package": { - "status": "pending_local_direct_source", - "documents": [], + "status": "official_catalog_item_metadata_verified", + "documents": [ + { + "source_url": "https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992/variable/V39", + "role": "ideation variable metadata", + "page_or_section": "WHO NCD Microdata Repository catalog" + }, + { + "source_url": "https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992/variable/V40", + "role": "plan variable metadata", + "page_or_section": "WHO NCD Microdata Repository catalog" + }, + { + "source_url": "https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992/variable/V41", + "role": "attempt variable metadata", + "page_or_section": "WHO NCD Microdata Repository catalog" + }, + { + "source_url": "https://extranet.who.int/ncdsmicrodata/index.php/catalog/992", + "role": "study universe and sampling metadata", + "page_or_section": "WHO NCD Microdata Repository catalog" + } + ], "question_numbers": null, - "source_language_evidence": [], - "note": "No country questionnaire or codebook for this component was found in the local source package." + "source_language_evidence": [ + "English catalog literal-question metadata" + ], + "note": "The official catalog provides literal questions, response categories, case counts, universe, and sampling metadata. A country questionnaire file and actual administration-language evidence were not located." }, "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": null, diff --git a/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.md b/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.md index 92bbc9f..cad8a3f 100644 --- a/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.md +++ b/research/stage1/gshs_primary_outcome_component_audit.md @@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ The country questionnaires and ordinary codebooks identify three administered it | `IND_2022_GSHS_v01::ind_jaipur_2022` | India | 4,299 | 4,174 | 4,106 | 4,228 | local_questionnaire_and_codebooks_located | | `JAM_2023_GSHS_v01::jam_st_cath_2023` | Jamaica | 3,041 | 2,879 | 2,850 | 2,936 | local_questionnaire_and_codebooks_located | | `MNG_2023_GSHS_v01::mng2023` | Mongolia | 3,311 | 3,274 | 3,258 | 3,238 | local_questionnaire_and_codebooks_located | -| `SLB_2023_GSHS_v01::slb_2023` | Solomon Islands | 1,995 | 1,890 | 1,953 | 1,963 | pending_local_direct_source | +| `SLB_2023_GSHS_v01::slb_2023` | Solomon Islands | 1,995 | 1,890 | 1,953 | 1,963 | official_catalog_item_metadata_verified | | `WLF_2023_GSHS_v01::wlf_2023` | Wallis and Futuna | 919 | 894 | 907 | 905 | local_questionnaire_and_codebooks_located | ## Representation checks @@ -30,13 +30,13 @@ The country questionnaires and ordinary codebooks identify three administered it ## Source boundary -Local questionnaires plus raw and binary codebooks were located for 6 of the 7 components: Ghana, India, Jamaica, Mongolia, Morocco, and Wallis and Futuna. No country-specific Solomon Islands 2023 questionnaire/codebook was found locally, so that component remains pending direct-source acquisition. +Local questionnaires plus raw and binary codebooks were located for 6 components: Ghana, India, Jamaica, Mongolia, Morocco, and Wallis and Futuna. For Solomon Islands, the official WHO catalog directly provides the three literal questions, response categories, case counts, universe, and sampling metadata. A country questionnaire file and administration-language evidence were not located, so those narrower provenance fields remain pending. Available English/French/Mongolian files establish wording evidence but do not by themselves prove the language administered to every respondent. Exact sampled ages/grades, component-specific eligibility, and canonical missing reasons also remain unresolved. ## Gate 1 decision -Gate 1 remains **in progress**. This audit resolves the 191-component coverage question and the raw-versus-`_b_` representation issue, but it does not satisfy the population/missing-rule or two-human-reviewer requirements. All records remain provisional and are not approved for confirmatory analysis or anchor construction. +Gate 1 remains **in progress**. This audit resolves the 191-component coverage question, direct item-source coverage, and the raw-versus-`_b_` representation issue, but it does not satisfy all population/language/missing-rule or two-human-reviewer requirements. All records remain provisional and are not approved for confirmatory analysis or anchor construction. ## Reproduction diff --git a/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.json b/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.json index 2c5f5bf..a0c4012 100644 --- a/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.json +++ b/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "schema_version": "1.3", + "schema_version": "1.4", "generated_on": "2026-09-20", "status": "provisional", "allowed_uses": [ @@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ "source_url": null, "page_or_section": "Master_Columns plus component-specific questionnaire/codebook references in component audit", "present_in_local_data": true, - "source_verification_status": "direct_local_sources_verified_for_six_of_seven_observed_components", + "source_verification_status": "direct_sources_verified_for_all_seven_observed_components_six_local_packages_one_official_catalog", "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": null, "reviewer_2": null, @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ "construct": "suicide_attempt", "record_type": "administered_raw_candidate", "question_text": "During the past 12 months, how many times did you attempt suicide?", - "notes": "Country questionnaires and ordinary codebooks identify this as an administered item. Solomon Islands 2023 direct local source remains pending; population and missing rules are not approved." + "notes": "Country questionnaires/ordinary codebooks cover six components; official WHO catalog item metadata covers Solomon Islands 2023. Administration language and missing rules are not approved." }, { "survey": "GSHS", @@ -57,7 +57,7 @@ "source_url": null, "page_or_section": "Master_Columns plus component-specific questionnaire/codebook references in component audit", "present_in_local_data": true, - "source_verification_status": "direct_local_sources_verified_for_six_of_seven_observed_components", + "source_verification_status": "direct_sources_verified_for_all_seven_observed_components_six_local_packages_one_official_catalog", "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": null, "reviewer_2": null, @@ -65,7 +65,7 @@ "construct": "suicide_ideation", "record_type": "administered_raw_candidate", "question_text": "During the past 12 months, did you seriously consider attempting suicide?", - "notes": "Country questionnaires and ordinary codebooks identify this as an administered item. Solomon Islands 2023 direct local source remains pending; population and missing rules are not approved." + "notes": "Country questionnaires/ordinary codebooks cover six components; official WHO catalog item metadata covers Solomon Islands 2023. Administration language and missing rules are not approved." }, { "survey": "GSHS", @@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ "source_url": null, "page_or_section": "Master_Columns plus component-specific questionnaire/codebook references in component audit", "present_in_local_data": true, - "source_verification_status": "direct_local_sources_verified_for_six_of_seven_observed_components", + "source_verification_status": "direct_sources_verified_for_all_seven_observed_components_six_local_packages_one_official_catalog", "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": null, "reviewer_2": null, @@ -91,7 +91,7 @@ "construct": "suicide_plan", "record_type": "administered_raw_candidate", "question_text": "During the past 12 months, did you make a plan about how you would attempt suicide?", - "notes": "Country questionnaires and ordinary codebooks identify this as an administered item. Solomon Islands 2023 direct local source remains pending; population and missing rules are not approved." + "notes": "Country questionnaires/ordinary codebooks cover six components; official WHO catalog item metadata covers Solomon Islands 2023. Administration language and missing rules are not approved." }, { "survey": "YRBS", @@ -2004,7 +2004,7 @@ "source_url": null, "page_or_section": "Master_Columns plus component-specific questionnaire/codebook references in component audit", "present_in_local_data": true, - "source_verification_status": "direct_local_sources_verified_for_six_of_seven_observed_components", + "source_verification_status": "direct_sources_verified_for_all_seven_observed_components_six_local_packages_one_official_catalog", "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": null, "reviewer_2": null, @@ -2032,7 +2032,7 @@ "source_url": null, "page_or_section": "Master_Columns plus component-specific questionnaire/codebook references in component audit", "present_in_local_data": true, - "source_verification_status": "direct_local_sources_verified_for_six_of_seven_observed_components", + "source_verification_status": "direct_sources_verified_for_all_seven_observed_components_six_local_packages_one_official_catalog", "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": null, "reviewer_2": null, @@ -2060,7 +2060,7 @@ "source_url": null, "page_or_section": "Master_Columns plus component-specific questionnaire/codebook references in component audit", "present_in_local_data": true, - "source_verification_status": "direct_local_sources_verified_for_six_of_seven_observed_components", + "source_verification_status": "direct_sources_verified_for_all_seven_observed_components_six_local_packages_one_official_catalog", "review_status": "provisional", "reviewer_1": null, "reviewer_2": null, diff --git a/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.md b/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.md index bf5230c..9c68cd3 100644 --- a/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.md +++ b/research/stage1/primary_outcome_registry.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Primary outcome source registry -Version: 1.3 | Status: provisional | Generated: 2026-09-20 +Version: 1.4 | Status: provisional | Generated: 2026-09-20 ## Scope and decision boundary @@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ This registry captures source-linked candidates for suicide ideation, plan, and | Survey | Ideation | Plan | Attempt | Current evidence boundary | |---|---:|---:|---:|---| -| GSHS | 1 | 1 | 1 | Three administered items occur in 7/191 components; local direct sources cover 6/7, with Solomon Islands pending. | +| GSHS | 1 | 1 | 1 | Three administered items occur in 7/191 components; six local source packages plus WHO catalog metadata cover all seven. | | YRBS | 17 | 17 | 17 | 51 annual candidates directly cross-checked; 21 prior mappings corrected; 2021/2023 data remain quarantined. | | NSDUH | 4 | 4 | 4 | Attempt is administered as YSUI03/YUSUICTRY, but the raw and recoded attempt fields are absent from the local public-use package. | @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ Counts are source-record counts, not distinct item families. YRBS counts include ## Gate 1 status -Gate 1 remains **in progress**. Before any candidate can enter confirmatory analysis, the project still needs the Solomon Islands GSHS source, exact population and skip-logic verification, canonical response/missing rules, validated YRBS 2021/2023 imports, and two actual human reviewers for primary outcomes. +Gate 1 remains **in progress**. Before any candidate can enter confirmatory analysis, the project still needs exact remaining population/language and skip-logic verification, canonical response/missing rules, validated YRBS 2021/2023 imports, and two actual human reviewers for primary outcomes. ## Reproduction